jhycc
  • jhycc
  • Member Topic Starter
2015-08-07T15:58:58Z
I have some questions regardinh pendulum monsters.
1) Can solemn judgement negate pendulum monsters when the player placed them on the scale?
2) Can the player set pendulum monsters on the scale if monsters like Horus Level 8, Silent swordman or anti spell frangrance is face up on the field?
3) Can cards like Horus level 8 or koai ki meiru wall and sandman negate pendulum effect?
4) Odd eyes rebellion dragon cannot destroy face down monster right?

Snarky
2015-08-07T16:06:31Z
I am no ruling expert, but I am pretty sure about these:
Originally Posted by: jhycc 


1) Can solemn judgement negate pendulum monsters when the player placed them on the scale?


Activating a Pendulum scale is treated as activating a Spell Card. So yes.
Quote:


2) Can the player set pendulum monsters on the scale if monsters like Horus Level 8, Silent swordman or anti spell frangrance is face up on the field?


No, he cannot. Pendulum monsters cannot be set as spells.
Quote:


3) Can cards like Horus level 8 or koai ki meiru wall and sandman negate pendulum effect?


Depends. Horus, Wall and Sandman can negate the activation of a Spell Card only, so they can negate the activation of a Pendulum monster as a spell card. They cannot negate the effect of a Pendulum monster already placed in the Pendulum zone before (eg Qliphort Scout's search effect). Same for Solemn Judgment btw.

There are cards, that can negate those effects as well, though, usually cards that state, that they can negate a card OR effect (Quasar, Infinity...)
Quote:


4) Odd eyes rebellion dragon cannot destroy face down monster right?


A face-down monster is not considered to have a level, so Odd-Eyes Rebelion Dragon cannot destroy it, even if you know, that it has a level and would be a valid target while face-up.
jhycc
  • jhycc
  • Member Topic Starter
2015-08-07T16:14:31Z
Cool, you are fast.